Cut.ProCut.Pro

Brands now pay creators to make their ads: how to price it

Brands are hiring creators to produce their ads, not just to post on their own profiles, Digiday reports. I explain why this is growing, the three ways a brand pays, and how to build your price when the brand is buying your video and not your audience.

Brands now pay creators to make their ads: how to price it

Brands now pay creators to make their ads: how to price it

Brands are hiring creators to produce their own ads, and not just to post on the creators' profiles, according to a Digiday report published on November 20. The reason is practical: brands need more and more video to feed social ads, and creators deliver it more cheaply than a production company. My take is that this changes what you sell. In this kind of contract the brand is buying your production skills, not your audience, and anyone still pricing by follower count is charging for the wrong thing.

Why do brands need so much video?

Because social ads eat creative, and each campaign now asks for more assets than before. Digiday cites a study from CreativeX, a company that measures ad quality, covering 115,990 campaigns and US$ 11 billion in media: the number of assets per campaign rose 30% in five years. I couldn't find the public CreativeX report, so the number is credited to Digiday.

The same study has the data point I find most important for anyone producing: in an average campaign, just five assets get 88% of the media money. The brand orders a lot, tests everything, and puts the budget behind the winners. The rest barely runs, or doesn't run at all.

Add the aesthetics argument. The professionals Digiday spoke to say audiences read a creator's look, language and way of filming as native to TikTok and Instagram, while polished studio production stands out from the feed. The report says Nike is learning this the hard way. Jared Kozel, from the agency Super Nice, put it this way: buying space in the feed doesn't buy attention.

How much money is in this?

The slice is still small, but it's the fastest growing. According to Madison & Wall, content that a brand pays a creator to produce and use in ads is 12% of advertiser spending on creators and is expected to grow 16% a year through 2030. I broke down the rest of the math, the US$ 116 billion in 2026, in the post on how much brands will spend on creators.

What Digiday adds is where this money comes from. Per Madison & Wall's research, production budgets may also be coming from public relations, social media and experimental budgets, besides traditional media and production. Nicholas Spiro, from the agency Viral Nation, said brands increasingly plan creators inside media budgets, not as a separate "influence" line. For you, that means negotiating with people who used to buy commercials from production companies and know exactly what a piece used to cost.

Does it work better than the brand's own ads?

There's evidence in favor, but from a single study and on a single network. The Creator Effectiveness Playbook, launched in July by System1 with WPP Media and TikTok, analyzed 1,217 paid ads on TikTok, 620 of them from creators, with about 183,000 users. Creator ads generated 23% more brand recall than ads made by the brand itself.

The same study found a detail that undermines a lot of sales pitches: engagement (likes, comments, shares) had almost no relationship with brand recall. Digiday cites another study, from June, by System1 with WPP Media and Goat: for category-leading brands, creator ads raised brand awareness 3.2 times more than traditional advertising creative. That's a cut of leaders only, so I wouldn't use that number as a promise for just any brand.

The three ways a brand pays

Digiday describes three models, and each calls for a different price:

Model What the brand buys What you deliver Where the risk is
Creative fee The video or photo, to use as it wishes within the contract Final file, sometimes in several formats A license with no term or channel in writing
Ad through your profile (the market calls it whitelisting) Your name and photo at the top of the ad, with the audience it picks Ad code or permission on your account Your face running as an ad for weeks
Licensed UGC Video from regular people, not dependent on audience Video shot with a user's look Low price and heavy competition

UGC stands for user-generated content. In advertising, it has become the name for a video someone records for a brand to use in an ad, often without posting it on their own profile.

Running ads through your profile is the one that most affects your name. On Instagram and Facebook it's called a partnership ad; on TikTok, Spark Ads. Olivia Wedderburn, from the agency Born Social, told Digiday that brands are pulling money from media budgets to pay for creator development and fund this format, and that negotiating usage rights and exclusivity has become much more complicated.

What changes in the price?

It's going up, and for the right reason. Agency professionals Digiday spoke to said creator fees rose 10% to 20% over the past year because of demand for broader usage rights. The brand wants to use the video in more places, for longer, and pays for that when the creator asks.

Now cross that with the 88% data point. If a brand orders 20 assets and only five get almost all the media money, yours may not be one of them. That's why I'd split the price like this:

  1. Production, always paid, whether the video runs or not. This is the line the brand compares with a production company.
  2. Posting on your profile, when there is any, as a separate deliverable.
  3. Paid usage by period, charged per 30 days. If the piece wins the test and runs for three months, you get paid three times.
  4. Ads through your profile, with a written term and its own price, because in practice it blocks other brands in the same category, even without an exclusivity clause.

The math on how much to charge per month of usage, with research ranges and an example in reais, is in the post on what to negotiate in a brand deal. On TikTok, whoever generates the Spark Ads code picks the validity: 7, 30, 60 or 365 days. Generate the term in the contract, never the longest one.

Who wins and who loses?

Small creators who film well win. In this kind of contract follower count weighs less, and brands were already shifting budget to micro and nano creators because of the lower cost. Someone with 8,000 followers and a portfolio of ads that performed well can compete for the same budget as someone with 800,000.

Traditional production companies lose, watching production budget flow to creators. And creators who hand over paid usage as a freebie lose too, because that's exactly the line getting more expensive.

There's a catch I wouldn't hide from anyone: the brands' core argument is that creators are cheaper. Digiday notes that some brands are turning to generative AI for the same reason. If your only value is price, you're competing with a machine that costs less. What AI doesn't deliver as easily is what the System1 study pointed to as decisive: emotion, the brand showing up early, and a creator who fits the brand.

What about Brazil?

Digiday's report has no Brazilian data. What exists about Brazil comes from the same Madison & Wall study: according to Meio & Mensagem, campaigns in the Brazilian market tend to spend proportionally more than average on creator-produced content.

The tools are the same: partnership ads and Spark Ads work for any brand advertising there. One detail applies only to the Brazilian market. An ad running through your profile is still sponsored content with your face on it, and since the Senacon ordinance, disclosure has been a government rule. Check that the ad the brand puts up with your @ is labeled as advertising.

What to do starting today

Build an ad portfolio, separate from your profile. Three to five short product videos, with a hook in the first seconds, show whoever buys creative what they'll receive. If any of them has already run as an ad, ask the brand for the results and use them with permission.

Sell variations, not a single piece. The brand tests a lot and invests in the winner, so the same script with three different hooks and in two formats is worth more than one perfect video. You can get those versions from a single recording: the AI clips from Cut.Pro pull segments out of a long video, and the editor exports the same clip in 9:16, 1:1 or 16:9 with captions.

Finally, write down each budget line and the term for each use before sending the proposal. None of this guarantees a contract, and the creator-made content slice is still the smallest part of the pie. But it's the one growing fastest, and the creator who knows how to charge for production and usage separately is the one who gets it.

Share

Keep reading

More insights and tutorials to help you grow as a content creator.